Warum O2
Warenkorb
Service
Gelöst

residency self certification


Hi, 

I had to make a quick decision to move to Italy before Christmas.

During lockdown in Germany, it wasn’t practical or safe to go into town just to buy stamps to send the official letter (cancelling 2 mobiles and internet), besides, I saw that I would still need to provide evidence that I was resident in Italy.  And of course, one would expect a firm like o2 to make it easy for the customer and use 21st Century technology like email and online contract changes (I incorrectly thought).

Italy has also been under lockdown so getting the correct documents about proof of residence is not straightforward. Indeed, it took over a month and then they are still unable to give me a certificate. Under Italian law, self-certification is possible and I have done this for a number of matters in Italy. I now also have the correct documentation from the German authorties that my residency has terminated. 

I did try to send documentation by fax using an email service (who owns a fax any more?) but there was no confirmation from o2 so I have to accept that as MY failing: “o2 customer can't leave because he doesn't own a fax machine”.

Now, most of Italy is Yellow Zone, I can go and post these documents - the risk of serving o2 bureacracy is lower (but not zero).

My first question is: is self-certification of my Italian residency acceptable to o2.de (as it is everywhere in Italy)

My second question is: do you agree that, frankly, in the 21st century, forcing customers to use snail mail and faxes makes o2 look either pathetically out-of-date and one can only conclude it is designed to make it hard for customers to leave and therefore represents a failure of customer care. I was able to cancel my utilities by email but, shamefully, not o2.

My third question is: given there is a pandemic, demanding faxes and letters puts o2 customers as risk of Covid-19 infection and it really ought to behave with more flexibility and understanding - time to grow up and act responsibily perhaps?

My fourth question is: why would anyone ever recommend someone moving to Germany getting an o2 contract given it’s so difficult to leave and the company charges three months for nothing?

Sorry to the employee who has to answer this and justify o2’s antiquated and opportunist treatment of customers. Nothing personal.

 

Edit by o2_Katja: Verschoben in unsere Englisch Community

icon

Lösung von o2_Lars 11 February 2021, 08:34

Zur Antwort springen

16 Antworten

Like the mafia, it is easy to join O2 but they make it difficult to leave.  Maybe everyone needs to know this before they ever sign up with O2?

Edit o2_Lars: Moved to existing thread..

Hello,

I have also left Germany and want to cancel internet and two mobile phones. I realise that o2 is desperate for money (financial difficulties perhaps?) and will make me pay for a few months more but is it possible to do all of this by email - given O2 is a 21st century company and not one of those ridiculous organisations that still asks for faxes and letters AND that there’s a global pandemic which makes buying stamps an infection risk AND that o2 is a customercentric organisation?

I sent a cancallation letter by fax a month ago but no confirmation - that’s my responsibility as I did it using one of those free online fax services (and it may not have worked) but, after all, who - apart from dinosaurs - uses fax?  

My experience of o2 so far is that they get you into a contract and you can’t stop paying them - even for no service after you have left - because they make it hard to leave. Is that a fair comment or is it all, predictably, the customer’s fault?

Thanks

David

Edit o2_Lars: Moved to existing thread.

Benutzerebene 7
Abzeichen +7

o2 charges three months as a penalty because you wish to terminate your contract early! This is provided for in the telecommunication law and charged by every other provider in Germany as well. What you CAN recommend is that people don’t sign up for a 24 month contract but choose a month-by-month contract instead if they want to be able to cancel easily at any time.

What do you mean by “self-certification”? From other posts in the forum it seems that o2 generally accepts any document that shows that you are ordinarily resident in the country you have moved to (an invoice with your address on it for example).

By the way, Email is a 20th century technology from the 1980s!

o2 charges a “penalty” - I spent nearly four years with 02, spent a fortune, and they “penalise” their own customers for leaving like we’ve done something wrong! These firms rabbit on about the free-market and deregulation but don’t like it when the customer expresses free choice. Buyer beware!

“Self-certification” in Italy is when you fill in a form provided by the local authorities to say you are resident at an address and sign it yourself - you “self” certify rather than being certified by the authorities.

Yes,of course you are right that email is from last century as well - too modern for o2 in this case - the point being that it is widely used elsewhere these days. Are you saying, all firms should only use fax and letters?  As said, even the utilities firm (hardly a beacon of modernity) allows customers to close accounts using email for sums of money that dwarf what I will have to pay.  But not o2 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Anyway, I know I have to pay the three months “because it’s in the contract” - I am not trying to evade payment - but, I’m a “paying customer”, o2 claims to want feedback and here it is.

What I CAN recommend also is to avoid o2 like the plague - they ripped me off in the UK and told me lies, so perhaps it’s not accidental.   

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

 

edit o2_Tobias: some sentences were deleted according to our netiquette

Benutzerebene 7
Abzeichen +7

o2 UK and o2 Germany are two completely separate companies. Seems like you have had a streak of bad luck then.

The “self-certification” should be OK as it is an official form.

Fan-boys? Please don’t embarrass yourself by using childish words to justify your argument. You are entitled to voice your criticism but you should at least respect other people’s views! If that comment was specifically addressed at me: I for one am not defending anybody (why should I?), merely stating the facts. You don’t have to agree, and I certainly don’t agree with everything o2 does either. And no, of course I am not saying companies should only communicate via fax and letters.

Incidentally, every provider will have happy und unhappy customers. I happen to know at least two people who have had terrible experiences with Italian providers, for example ;-)

The experience with o2 is not bad luck. There is a shared and highly profitable business model and policy.

I don’t trust o2 to accept self-certification. Due to Covid, getting the right documents, printing them, sending them from the post-office by certified post, etc., is a long, expensive and frustrating process that puts my health and the health of others at risk. Given that other non-communications firms have managed it and o2 doesn’t, it raises questions as to motivation and responsibility.

Funny how some posters get to use a term but mine was censored. It’s a real term with a real meaning as is the accusation (second person use) levelled at me of childishness.  What better word was there to use? Sycophants?  Why would I be embarrassed – it’s my perception of the set-up.

It was not specifically addressed to you but to two points. The first is that o2 hides behind this community instead of providing a proper customer service. Customers ask questions and the company leaves it to individual posters to respond. Secondly, the reply to my post was a patronising justification for the company punishing its own customers and completely unhelpful (though it helps o2, which I guess was the point). The result manifests as a kind of defensive sycophancy that shields the company by using “third-party enthusiasts” to find a way to make out that the company is right and its customers are wrong. In this way, o2 avoid having to justify their behaviour because they have created an environment where others do it for them. They evade responsibility. Whether you are wittingly or otherwise being exploited in this way is not for me to say.  

It’s simply not good enough for o2 to say, “every provider will have happy and unhappy customers” but of course they didn’t – someone else posted it on their behalf so they can’t even own that trite truism.

The “terrible experience” with Italian providers is not the joke the emoji at the end of the sentence makes it out to be. There are serious consequences to what these organisations do, no less than the terrible experience with other utilities providers. Perhaps on reflection, it might be agreed that it is not the joking matter, the second reply might imply. Would o2 go on record stating that terrible provider experience is a joke? Well, they don’t need to because someone has done it for them.

About Italian providers, I know dozens of people who have had terrible experiences with Italian providers. I have had appalling experiences with at least four of them – far worse than o2 even.  This explains why I didn’t complain about the first two problems with o2 and, given the response (not from o2 but from someone they hid behind), I now realise I was right - it would have been a waste of time anyway.  The lesson is: the company is always right, the customer is always wrong, just pay the money, don’t complain, protest as much as you like but only use words we approve of so long as nothing changes, we’re not the worst in the world, so that’s all right then.

Benutzerebene 7

Hello @vidgro and welcome to our o2 community :-)

Sometimes in life things change just with a snap. You move to another city or even another country. Still you have contract signed that run for a period of time.

Just some years ago if you signed a contract for a fixed line connection for a two-year-period you had to pay for the full time even if you moved to an area or a foreign country wre the connection cound not be established.

Nowadays it is possible to cancel such a contract to an earlier date if all necessary documents are provided with just an additional three months fee. 

If you need a contract that fits spontaneous situations we also offer so called Flex versions of our tariffs that can be canceled within a months notice.

Regards,

Lars

Sorry Lars but if we unpack what you are saying, you seem to be arguing that customers should be grateful because it was worse in the past. Also, “just three months” trivialises the sums involved. I’ve had o2 internet and two mobile SIMS for four years, purchased two expensive smartphones and suffered two instances of poor customer service (lies about date of connection and about the SIMS) which I didn’t complain about.  

You are justifying the company making customers pay and extra three months “penalty” for leaving the country. Penalty!  I’m not trying to evade payment - if o2 has financial problems that if needs ex-customers to help with, it’s in the contract.  But actually, because of Covid-19 and o2 insistance on using fax and letters and the hostile anti-customer attitude that means I can’t trust o2, it is more than three months because a. I need to get Italian residency certificate under Covid restrictions (almost impossible) and I have to send everything by registered post.  EVEN UNDER COVID, o2 IS INFLEXIBLE AND UNHELPFUL. IT INCONCENIENCES THE CUSTOMERS. BY FORCING CUSTOMERS TO GET ALL THESE DOCUMENTS AND SEND THEM BY POST, o2 IS RISKING MY HEALTH AND THE HEALTH OF OTHERS! What kind of customer service is that?!

o2 is a telecommunications firm that could easily accept contracts being terminated by email yet it refuses to do so because it knows that making it easier for customers to leave, removes the extra costs.

So, o2 hide behind contracts and procedures and processes and being better than in the past or some other companies - a typical “inside-out” organisation - and in doing so demonstrates an unhealthy attitude to customers. 

Potential customers should be warned that there are hidden costs when they leave. As you say, it’s in the contract so, I think this message from o2 needs to be amplified, don’t you?

o2 will have its pound of flesh and I will pay up - I have no choice - but in the long run, the company will lose out.  This behaviour will lose you potential customers and revenue.  I’ll make sure of that!

And lo and behold… different company but same mentality - maybe the German authorities will launch an investigation too… https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/feb/12/o2-fined-105m-for-customer-overcharging-over-almost-a-decade What’s the English word for Schadenfreude?

I’m sure there are o2 fans in the UK who will filling their forums defending o2.uk for this too. If only there was a collective noun to describe them…

 

Benutzerebene 7

Hello @vidgro,

you will find the information regarding the three months base fee in §46 TKG.

Regards,

Lars

Thanks Lars,

I already know about the three months base fee. That’s not really the problem here, is it? The problem is that O2 deliberately make it difficult to end the contract. It takes the three months money, which I’ve never contested. It also insists on fax or letter even though it is a telecommuncations company and there is a worldwide pandemic. It’s sticking with this backward, anti-customer, approach, which is its right. It’s also the right of customers to tell others about this particularly squalid approach. 

Actually, a decent company would regard my feedback, however irritating and disagreeable, as helpful but, it seems, with its fanclub forum, the only feedback it wants is positive and there is only a cosemetic attempt at customer service. 

Benutzerebene 7

Hello @vidgro,

keep in mind that this community is in no way a support forum. In this community customer help pother customers. In many cases we modertators have a look into things and help if necessary.

Feedback from customer is valued and always taken into consideration but there ar alwyas things that we in our community can not change and will not discuss. 

I am sorry to hear that the cancelation process does not meet your expectations, unfortunately there is no way that we can change about it. A cancelation is possible via phone after preregistering for cancelation, via postal mail or via fax. If documents are needed to cancel any contract to an earlier date the possibility to send this documents are either postal mail or fax.

Regards,

Lars

Yes, you are right that the community has its limits - by design rather than accident.

Thank you for you empathy and the admission that I can complain as much as I like but nothing will change. Is this ethically questionable or am I not allowed to ask?

De facto this forum supports the current situation: a telecommunications company that only accepts cancellation by fax and snail mail; a company that makes no concession for difficulties caused by Covid-19 because of its “rigidity”.

The mobile contracts were cancelled last week - I just have to pay the three months extra (plus I’ve been paying two months extra due to the fax/letter diktat).

I’ve had zero reply about the internet cancellation or sending back the router from abroad (for which I am prepared to pay out of my own pocket but do not know which courier to send it to).  I guess if I’m forced to keep it and pay for it, I can cover the costs smashing it to pieces on a YouTube channel as some kind of childish metaphor for o2.

I sent cancellation of both phone and internet by the risky - and expensive - process of going to the local Post Office and using registerd post with a return slip. This will demonstrate that o2 have received the cancellation so any attempt to take money me beyond the three months will be reported as theft tothe police. They can then investigate whether o2 has committed any crimes or not. Let’s hope not, eh?

How much is your sorrow worth Lars? A hundred euro? 200?  Ideally, your sorrow would be worth you lobbying o2 to change its behaviour and see it as valuable feedback. If you are not part of the solution, you’re part of the problem. Angry customers - even ex-customers - are bad for business. Surely, changing behaviour will benefit o2 more than the relative (to them) pittance, it continues to take from my personal bank account. 

What does the company have to do to turn and angry customer like me into someone who says, “I was angry with o2 for a long time, but you’ve got to give them credit - they responded, admitted their failings and were mature enough to change things to meet customer need.”  That’s the litmus test and believe me, it can and has been done. Even with me.

This is not about the three months - that’s bad but it’s written down - it’s about the obstacles the company sets up to delay someone leaving; it’s about making people (who don’t own fax machines!) leave the house to send a letter and risk receiving and giving Covid-19.  Is that a responsible approach?

For the umpteenth time the bit of the website with my data on says, "Aus technischen Gründen können Ihre Daten derzeit nicht vollständig geladen werden. Bitte versuchen Sie es zu einem späteren Zeitpunkt erneut" Four years of it! At one point can I become impatient with it?

So the contract has ended, I will happily pay to return the router from abroad from my own pocket but no idea still where to send.

O2 continues to help itself to my bank account like a hungry dog licking a discarded kebab. Would you like me to set up a crowdfunding page for O2, once I have been forced to close my bank account to stop them emptying it? Share the love, eh?

Think of it as the first of many expensive and unforgettable parting gifts you will be unable to refuse.

Hi @vidgro 

Your contract will be deactivated march 31th. , the day after tomorrow. 

a last invoice will follow in April. 

The address the o2 router goes to is 

Telefónica Germany GmbH & Co. OHG
 c/o KOMSA Kommunikation Sachsen AG Logistikzentrum
 Wittgensdorfer Höhe 400
 09228 Chemnitz 

Best Regards Matze 

 

 

Thank you Matze, much appreciated. 

I will send it by courier so I have delivery on record. 

Deine Antwort